Home › minatasgeel › Comments
minatasgeel
About
- Username
- minatasgeel
- Joined
- Visits
- 18,545
- Last Active
- Roles
- Administrator
Comments
-
[quote author=ophadece link=topic=10975.msg133124#msg133124 date=1300278211] Dear jydeacon, What I meant is the introduction of psalm 150 recorded by cantor Ibrahim is different to the one by Fr. Metthias. The former I don't believe in, but I do in …
-
[quote author=kmeka001 link=topic=10986.msg133112#msg133112 date=1300257590] Now that we are on the subject of the feast of the cross, is Fai Etaf Enf chanted in its regular pascha tune? [/quote] yes. that "way" rather is its unique one that goes wi…
-
[quote author=the_least link=topic=10928.msg133105#msg133105 date=1300248342] why not have a section on tasbeha.org for this... people always come here for hymns anyways so we might as well tell them about the changes [/quote] not much have been giv…
-
[quote author=baladoos link=topic=10986.msg133101#msg133101 date=1300244801] Hi All, I have a question about the coming Feast of the cross on Sunday. Do we say Tai Shory or Tee Shory? Cantor Ibrahim Ayad says (on his tapes) that we say Tee Shory. …
-
[quote author=the_least link=topic=10928.msg133093#msg133093 date=1300233027] so where can we find these changes that happen and have happened? is it published in the keraza? is there a website? I think people don't follow all of this because no on…
-
[quote author=epiphania link=topic=10984.msg133086#msg133086 date=1300231231] The priest or bishop carries maintains their title even if they can't physically carry out their duties. Someone else does it in their place until they pass on. [/quote] i…
-
[quote author=Cyril97 link=topic=10928.msg133077#msg133077 date=1300225592] I asked what is the holy synod and I know that they decide to make changes in... hymns for example. Where can I know these changes? I will try to ask abouna to make a deacon…
-
oh come on....don't say that.
-
i am with Remnkemi :)
-
[quote author=ophadece link=topic=10975.msg133043#msg133043 date=1300180087] St. James advises us not to be too many teachers for in many things we ALL stumble... I can see many things done in hymns nowadays only on a whim and caprice rather than st…
-
[quote author=ophadece link=topic=10975.msg133039#msg133039 date=1300175675] ... THat's why I don't believe in Cantor Ibrahim's joyful recording... OUJai [/quote] well....he follows a teaching rather than a recording. that is acceptable.....not to m…
-
[quote author=aem581 link=topic=10975.msg133036#msg133036 date=1300165174] No, dude, I mean like different tunes even on regular Sundays... [/quote] none that we know about. i actually believe that we might of lost some psalm tunes across the years.…
-
[quote author=Unworthy1 link=topic=10973.msg133023#msg133023 date=1300151095] It would only make sense that if an Orthodox person were to marry a non-Orthodox person outside of the church in a secular ceremony, or even a non-secular ceremony they sh…
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10973.msg133018#msg133018 date=1300149802] Minatasgeel clearly is unaware then that if an orthodox Christian marries outside the orthodox faith, there are repercussions. [/quote] well i haven't been reading much abo…
-
[quote author=lightening link=topic=10973.msg133006#msg133006 date=1300147364] zox, did you know that the priest is allowed to marry more than once?... :o i am sure you know that. ...coz he marries every bride and groom on their wedding day!! :D …
-
[quote author=aem581 link=topic=10975.msg132993#msg132993 date=1300142601] What would be the fast annual tune, Mina? I am pretty sure there are about a billion variations when it comes to Psalms because there so many schools of teaching and changes …
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10973.msg132977#msg132977 date=1300141038] So Father, let me explain this: Let's say I am an Orthodox Christian, and I fall in love with a protestant lady. She's protestant, and I'm Orthodox. If i get married OU…
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10935.msg132968#msg132968 date=1300140145] Sorry, you've lost me. I was discussing the issue with respect to my personal experience. [/quote] well i guess i didn't mean to quote this specific response of yours but …
-
[quote author=Κηφᾶς link=topic=10973.msg132955#msg132955 date=1300136623] + Irini nem ehmot, Don't you think you're being a little over the top now? Some people here may not have shown you proper Christian charity, but does that give you the right …
-
[quote author=ophadece link=topic=10975.msg132938#msg132938 date=1300126397] WHat's the recommendation got anything to do with the answer Mina? Fast tune, or longer tune both are still chanted in fasting. We also sing abanshois on the tune of other …
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10935.msg132935#msg132935 date=1300125906] Fr. Peter, This really worries me.. because I HAD reached a point of not taking the priest's comments seriously about certain things because I felt that what they were sayi…
-
[quote author=jydeacon link=topic=10975.msg132913#msg132913 date=1300117921] Its annual, je afsaji for vespers, ouini afshai for liturgy [/quote] i would also recommend the fast annual tune instead of ou-oinee afshai which does have many parts of t…
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10935.msg132928#msg132928 date=1300124389] OK. .this is a bit hard because you are not Egyptian Orthodox. But, if a priest says he doesn't "recommend" or he "discourages" something - its as good as "banned". Perha…
-
[quote author=Zoxsasi link=topic=10935.msg132871#msg132871 date=1300065916] Arrrgghh... I hate word-games. "We discourage it, but we don't ban it". The Coptic Orthodox Church is not a state. It is not a legal system. It doesn't ban anything. It …
-
[quote author=Cyril97 link=topic=10941.msg132832#msg132832 date=1300044884] Just a little side note, in Albair's book, it says A Isos ... GB, PFM, Cyril [/quote] well it's a recently published book.
-
[quote author=Remnkemi link=topic=10963.msg132820#msg132820 date=1299988183] What are you talking about Mina? There is a special vesper service that is found in the Powerpoint presentation. Additional hymns include the Verse of Cymbals for the 24 p…
-
[quote author=lightening link=topic=10738.msg132790#msg132790 date=1299923676] well... we need not get carried away, minatasgeel. there was nothing in what i said to suggest that i was looking for an 'argument'. and i am not going to accept you invi…
-
[quote author=mechaiel link=topic=10963.msg132793#msg132793 date=1299937617] Hi everyone, Next Saturday, we will have a new priest ordained for our church. I've never attended a priest ordination before. I am the leading deacon at our church, so I'…
-
[quote author=copticuser20 link=topic=10929.msg132780#msg132780 date=1299904626] Oh sorry...I was commenting on your comment: [quote author=minatasgeel link=topic=10929.msg132333#msg132333 date=1299552716] i just wanted to comment on this; fasts in…
-
[quote author=lightening link=topic=10738.msg132749#msg132749 date=1299872531] without agreeing or disagreeing with your classification, i would like to say that what makes protestantism distinct from catholicity and orthodoxy is not the view about …