Why are you Christian for? Why do you believe?

Dear brothers and sisters,

I'm preparing a Bible Study  - but to address it well, I'd just like to ask you a few a questions as to why you are Christian:

I am just curious to know why you are Christian?

Christ rose from the dead - but did you witness His Resurrection? 

Only when the disciples and apostles saw Him Risen did they believe. Without the Resurrection, they would have never believed. 

The miracles they witnessed before (healings, Lazarus etc) made absolutely zero difference. It was only when seeing Christ Risen did they believe. 

If an atheist came here and asked you : Why are you all Coptic? You'd say that your parents were Coptic. Why aren't you Muslim? If your parents were born in Pakistan or Saudia Arabia, you'd have been Muslim, and equally defending your faith in Islam. 

The Gospels are telling you that without the resurrection, your faith is pointless. So what right do you have in saying you are Christian when the Apostles didn't believe and even saw tons of miracles. You seem to like the Christian ideology, but you have not had any evidence that Christ IS indeed Risen.

What is your evidence??

Oh, before I forget, I have the answer to these questions .. I just want to make sure I've perfected my Bible Study homework before I present it to our prayer group. 

Basically, the question asks: What claim do you have to say you are a Christian when you haven't seen Christ Risen?


  • Three reasons I choose to be Christian:

    1. Apostles who started Christianity, and preached that Christ was risen, died for that belief. It doesn't make sense to make something up and die for it. Mohammed would easily renounce Islam if you have a sword to his neck because he knows that s**t is made up. This is different from a follower of a religion dying for their belief because they truly believe it based on simple trust of the founder.

    2. There are modern miracles that have enough evidence to make them believable. In our wonderful Egyptian society where literally everything is a "miracle" the word loses its meaning. But if you look past all the dumb stories, there are well documented miracles that have at least some merit. Example would be someone with a terminal cancer that spontaneously regresses within a short period of time and findings are documented by a muslim physician. The miracles people witnessed from Jesus did make a difference ... he had a huge following. Jesus himself asked skeptics to believe in him because of the works he did (John 14:11). 

    3. Apparition of St. Mary in Zeitoun 1968 which was witnessed by a large number of people of many religions. At the very least, it gives credence to the existence of a "spiritual" world beyond the physical one. But it also gives merit to belief in Christianity specifically, with the apparition being in the shape of St. Mary and being over a church dome, etc...

    However, none of these is absolute evidence. Apostles could have all been brainwashed/crazy or maybe the historical evidence for their martyrdom is bogus. It is also possible that there are perfectly reasonable natural explanations for these "miracles" and the apparition. But you have to look at it in the context of Pascal's Wager (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S93jMOqF-oE). Pascal just arbitrarily assumed a 50% chance that God exists. But given the above points, I (and I think most reasonable people) would put it somewhere between 75-90%. Given these odds, you are better off living as a Christian to have a chance of going to heaven if it exists.

    Conclusion: There is nothing to prove Christianity beyond reasonable doubt. However, given the above evidence, it would be pragmatic to live as a Christian to avoid the very real possibility of going to hell and have a chance of going to heaven if they exist. 

    (This is just why I choose to be Christian, but I certainly don't speak for other Christians)
  • "There is nothing to prove Christianity beyond reasonable doubt."
    I do not agree with this. The church fathers have used many methods to prove Christianity such the prophesies and the natural arguments for God. www.reasonablefaith.com is a good resource even though it it protestant.

  • edited December 2020
    May I suggest you create the lesson in a different way? The entire argument is based on Western individualism. The "didn't witness" usage reeks of, "...if I didn't see it I don't believe it..." thought. Self is a relatively new thing to Copts. And not all of us are Coptic by ethnicity, nor is everyone Christian who are currently a part of the church.

    Maybe bring up how the faith survives beyond secular, ethnic and political conflicts? How our traditions and Traditions have been so "orthodox" with 1,500 years of separation? I agree with you're main point. Perhaps NOT about if an individual doesn't believe, but how God welcomes someone back? Use more universal examples of those doubted their faith and put it in contemporary examples and issues within the conversation, not the main them of the lesson.
  • edited December 2020
    I am a Christian because, after knowing the holy people that I have known, after experiencing their faith, I cannot not be Christian. After not only knowing them, but experiencing heaven itself, in prayer, in scripture, in the Divine Liturgy, in the confession. I know that there is no greater spiritual food than what I have here. Here, my spiritual food is God Himself, literally, in the Eucharist!
  • Replying to CanadianCopt: 

    Yes indeed there are a lot of philosophical attempts to "logic" God into existence. The majority of such arguments fall short either simply because they happen to be bad or circular arguments, or they fail to prove the existence of any particular god. I think this is a problem in our church and many other churches, trying to prove something (let alone a religion) beyond a reasonable doubt is such a huge undertaking that you are simply setting yourself up for failure. It is much easier, and more honest, to embrace the uncertainty and let people come to their own conclusions.

  • All things aside I have no better option.

    I will admit I left my former religion due to youthful irresponsibility, but my former religion heavily based itself as a successor to this one. So when I became agnostic and opened up to religion, I followed the path of the abrahamic faiths and found that it basically led me here and no further.

    While studying as an agnostic, I've had nothing but respect for Jesus Christ and what he brought, despite being iffy about giving full commitment worrying it would be another phase.

    That was nearly 3 years ago.

    If you have any questions you can ask me but to answer this one, I am christian because Jesus Christ changed me for the better, or in the least showed me what I must do to be better myself. He gave me a purpose and showed me a direction and warned me of the pain this direction will cause as well as the rewards that makes it worth it. I am christian because even if everything I did was false and if christianity as a whole was false, I will still be able to look the muslim God, hindu God whatever in the eye and tell him that the path I took is still worth it and if following the perfect man is something condemnable, then I will take it for the rest of eternity without a regret. I will be able to tell the false Gods and false inquisitor's that the Christ who gave us the church taught me to love my neighbors and pray for those who curse me. To seek the best even in the worst people, to forgive those who transgress against me and to treat them justly.

    And if God doesn't exist, and my life ends after I breath my last and get buried and have my body decompose and digested by worms. Then at least the illusion I set up for myself was a worthy one. For this "illusion" made me more of a man than anyone can make me, taught me to be a better human being and hopefully from the results of whatever kindness I could display, that others learn from it thus the domino affect. I'm no saint but this illusion I set up according to athiests allowed me at least to work and aim towards being the lamp for the light of Christ to shine for all to see, so that if we don't have a next world or next life, at least by everyone working to emulate christ, we at least created a heaven here.

    Thank God though we have a next one and I just hope to be worthy enough to be able to make it there.
  • that is really nice to hear 
Sign In or Register to comment.