It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It would not be preserved in 8 known manuscripts unless people considered it important and useful and went to the cost and effort of duplicating it.
Also, the last time I checked, Metropolitan Anba Bishoy was still Orthodox.
I see no point in anyone continuing this discussion with you.
I just want to say that I find it comical that you have decided what is authentic and what isn't!
What would theologians like Fr. Athanasius Iskander and Fr. Peter know about the authenticity of the father's teachings compared to great scholars like yourself!? (sarcasm, just in case you didn't pick up on it).
I do apologize for being an offense but I think this discussion has turned into nothing but sheer ignorance.
Fr. Tadros and Fr. Athanasius are quoting a valuable source
while you are quoting Anba Bishoy
This does not give you the right nor the authority to claim that what the great father St. Theodosius has said is a heresy. I'm not sure on what grounds you are claiming that this is a heresy.
You asked Dimas to "enlighten us"... Well you know, imikhail, it seems that many people have tried to enlighten you providing you with valuable sources,
It's obvious that you are not here to learn, but rather to teach all of us. I wouldn't mind that, but please use credible sources, and do not claim teachings on behalf of the church.
As fortunatus has said, this discussion with you is more vain than it is spiritual.
Also, what is your view on the Augustinian doctrine of inherited guilt/original sin?