Home › minatasgeel › Comments
minatasgeel
About
- Username
- minatasgeel
- Joined
- Visits
- 6,857
- Last Active
- Roles
- Administrator
Comments
-
@bashandy...I actually agree with you on how to deal with those madayeh. Concerning Coptic...so what I am understanding is, because Coptic is a "dead" language, the standards that are applied to other languages are not here?! It would be nice to get…
-
@bashandy...I am sure you are aware of the huge amount of Kiahk arabic hymns/madayeh/psalies/commentaries...all of the ones we have now may have been written in the last 6 centuries, this is considering the lives of many of the writers of which name…
-
Oh. So you're taking the stance of "lets not follow this rule just because we are not following this other one"...I get you...
-
@bashandy: concerning the dating, many conclude that it was Fr. Sarkis that wrote, and some conclude that Sarkis lived during 14-15 century: https://st-takla.org/articles/fr-basilous-sobhy/characters/sarkis.html
-
@mrpete33...you should put some time into understanding how canon law works... What you would like to call 'tradition' or 'Tradition' or 'acceptable' or not is totally arbitrary because you do not have any authority...neither do I or RamezM or minas…
-
That was a typo and i fixed it :-)
-
That is true. But it's harder to get to manuscripts...and a critical edition?! how in the world if we are still burning manuscripts in old churches, and those who do have ones just want to make money, and those who have ones and cherish them, don't …
-
A footnote we have in our bright saturday book:"The hymn is compiled of chosen parts of the Psalms. These parts have different versions. The source of these listed parts is “The Deacon’s Service & Hymns Book” of The Committee of the Revival of t…
-
I don't think we are saying anything other then both cases are acceptable. I think this is hard to consider without a deep look into how monasteries were through the centuries--they were not as isolated as they are now and many of them were in the m…
-
@Remenkemi...there are a couple of small monasteries that are like Texas situation...where they are part of the diocese, the abbot is the bishop of the diocese, but it still would have a "robbita" taking care of everything. We don't hear bout them b…
-
@minasoliman...if this trip proves anything, it would be that the Pope's trip to our area may be delayed longer than expected.
-
@minasoliman...the priests were not summoned to egypt, but they did the first "Northeastern USA Priests Convention" just because the Pope cancelled his visit that was supposed to take place this month.
-
@minasoliman...I don't think Abouna Athanasius concentrated on the 'woman' part as much as he did on where is the orban was being made. I think this is so based on how much he wrote concerning 'lawful" or 'unlawful' orban based on how it's made late…
-
God is good...i didn't have to look too far. Fr. Athanasius El-Makari has a book called "The Divine Liturgy: the Mystery of the Kingdom" (two parts). In the first part, page 180, section called "Baking the Orban and preparing it." The book is in ara…
-
@mrpete33...I think you're being too dismissive of these rules. But you know what, i'll actually spend time looking into it and get back to you.
-
@minasoliman...I am not actually sure. What i am saying is based on experience rather than a source. We never had a consecrated deaconess in church to be put in the position of them making the hamal. But we did have some old ladies at some point of …
-
oghnostos
-
The rule is, only "deacon ranks" are allow to do the orban that is presented of which the Lamb is chosen.
-
@ophadece I am not trying to drive anyone away. But there are limits to how much we can argue about something and there are standards to someone making a point. One of those standards is to try to understand and tolerate the other party's ideas and …
-
@ophadece...I am sorry, but now you are pushing it a little. GB is the current accepted pronunciation of Coptic in the church, therefore it's part of our heritage. If for any reason that developed into a different whole new pronunciation, that also …
-
-
There is a handful of people that are posing these allegations against Anba Daniel without any proof. I say without any proof because, if there was proof, these wouldn't be allegations anymore but facts....and it would of been really really hard for…
-
babros, i don't think you'll find a better an answer than what minasoliman said. Anyone who is Muslim is no difference than anyone who is not Christian. What other answer are you looking for exactly? Do you have a specific assumption that we can dis…
-
It good to know how things are done in other churches, specially if they are sister churches. But you have to consider that every local church may have it's own circumstances and view of things. In the Armenian church, they "ordain" (atleast that's …
-
1- these are canons that may be changes by the Synod2- this is a local council to, I think, Church of Antioch. So the Church of Alexandria were probably not bound to it
-
- Evol hiten is only part of the sunday midnight tasbeha.- Alli elasr is any vespers praise- aretenthoni is unique to saturday vespers praise- ti-galili a is unique to wednesday vespers praise and the feasts of entering egypt and the temple- the 8th…
-
the names of those mentioned after the Commemoration are the departed, not the living. As for all other prayers for the living, you're allowed to pray for anyone.
-
No.
-
@Remnkemi...how about putting together a quick document for a proper translation for the 3 main parts of the hymn? The latter verses are just "The blessing of...."
-
Fr. Peter recently wrote an article about this:http://www.stgeorgeministry.com/?p=1312