Bright Saturday

gergesezzat

Which tone do you briefer for bright Saturday communion it is Pe ehmot gar or E aghaby ?

ophadece

Dear gergesezzat,
I guess "biehmot ghar" tune is the more authentic as many cantors sing it this way, and I prefer it myself.
God bless you and pray for us a lot

jydeacon

I agree with ophadece, Piehmot ghar would be my preference. but i suggest you do whatever your church does regardless

minatasgeel

another thing with hymn, [coptic]PaNou] paNou][/coptic], is also how thereis more than one version of the text. untill now i have seen about 5 diffrent texts. they are basiclly psalm parts. i personnaly just like the one in the Nahdet- el-kanaies book, which is also recorded by Ibrahim Ayad in a beautiful way.

gergesezzat

Ok, What about Arabic version ? did any cantor record it in Arabic ?

minatasgeel

[quote author=gergesezzat link=topic=6502.msg86049#msg86049 date=1208524085]
Ok, What about Arabic version ? did any cantor record it in Arabic ?


there is a recording of Fr. Dawood, Panoti Panoti - Arabic by Fr. David Bebawy. i tihnk it follows the version that is in the khidmit shamas of cantor Farag.

Amoussa01

I dont know about you guys but i find the e aghapy tune much more beautiful!! It is much more musical to me....

oh well
P.S minagir, can you send the recording your talking about?

GB
Tony

minatasgeel

[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=6502.msg86060#msg86060 date=1208537333]
I dont know about you guys but i find the e aghapy tune much more beautiful!! It is much more musical to me....

oh well
P.S minagir, can you send the recording your talking about?

GB
Tony


link below......

Amoussa01

i am talking about the one you said ibrahim did

minatasgeel

[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=6502.msg86066#msg86066 date=1208555708]
i am talking about the one you said ibrahim did


also here, http://tasbeha.org/media/index.php?st=Hymns/Other_Occasions/Bright_Saturday/Ibrahim_Ayad/Part_3/13.Panoti_Panoti.1691.mp3